← Writing

Facebook is not your website

Picture a breeder who has been on Facebook for ten years. They post litters, answer questions, share photos, and have built up a few thousand followers. They do not have a website. When someone asks how to contact them, they say to message them on Facebook. When someone searches Google for their kennel name plus their town, nothing comes up except a Facebook Page that may or may not show in results depending on how Facebook feels about indexing that day. The breeder assumes the Page is their web presence. Then one day the Page is restricted for a policy violation they do not understand, or the reach drops and posts that used to be seen by hundreds of people are now seen by thirty, or Facebook changes the layout again and half the information they had pinned is no longer visible.

That is the common version. The worse version is when the Page is deleted, the account is locked, and there is no appeal that works. Everything they posted, every contact, every thread, gone. No backup, no export that is useful, no way to get it back. The breeder has no website, no email list, and no way for someone who heard about them to find them except by word of mouth.

A Facebook Page is a useful tool. It is not a website. It is not a replacement for a domain you own, a site you control, and a presence that shows up in search engines whether or not a platform decides to surface it.

What search engines see

When someone searches for your business name, your town, and your industry, Google is looking for pages it has indexed. It can index a normal website. It has a harder time indexing a Facebook Page. Facebook does allow some Pages to be indexed, but the content inside the Page, the posts, the photos, the detailed information, most of that is behind a login wall or rendered in a way that a search crawler does not parse well. The result is that someone searching for exactly what you do, in exactly the town you are in, will find your competitors who have websites and will not find you.

The other thing search engines look for is inbound links. If you have a website, other sites can link to it. Directories, industry groups, local listings, news articles, all of those can point to your domain. If all you have is a Facebook Page, those links go to Facebook, not to you. You do not build search authority. Facebook does.

What you do not control

You do not control who sees your posts. Facebook has an algorithm that decides whether your post is shown to the people who follow your Page. That percentage has been dropping for years. It is common now for a Page post to reach less than five percent of followers unless you pay to boost it. You can post something important, time-sensitive, or sales-related, and the majority of the people who explicitly chose to follow you will not see it.

You do not control the layout. Facebook changes the design of Pages regularly. Information that used to be prominent gets moved or hidden. Features get added and removed. You adapt or you lose functionality. There is no option to keep the version that worked.

You do not control access. If your account is compromised, or if Facebook decides your Page violates a policy, it can be restricted or removed. The appeal process is inconsistent. There is no phone number to call. You are at the mercy of an automated system and whatever human review you can manage to trigger.

Where a Page fits

A Facebook Page is a good place to have a presence if your customers are on Facebook. It is a good place to post updates, share photos, and interact with people who prefer that platform. It is not a good place to store your only copy of your contact information, your service list, your pricing, or your story. That belongs on a site you own, under a domain you control.

The pattern that works is a website that has the information someone needs to decide whether to contact you, and a Facebook Page that links back to that site and acts as one channel among several. The website is the hub. The Page is a spoke. If the Page goes away, you still have the site, the domain, the search presence, and the email address that is tied to your domain instead of to a platform.

RedCyfer hosting includes a domain, a site, and email under that domain. The site is something you own, that search engines can index, and that does not disappear when a platform changes its terms. A Facebook Page can point to it. It should not replace it.


Need this kind of thinking applied to your own setup? Get in touch →